I've been lurking on the boards for a while, enjoying the hunt--hope you don't mind if I jump in. I want to propose something a little radical (could be completely wrong, but I thought I'd throw it out here for comment).
I wonder if image 12, which we've been assuming to refer to NYC, could actually be paired with verse 10 and referring to Pittsburgh, PA. Here are my thoughts:
The solo rectangle in the left corner looks to me like the US Steel tower (USX tower) in downtown Pgh, which is one of the tallest buildings in the world. It is dark grey (the "grey giant" of verse 10?). If you cross the Monongahela river to the south side of Pgh, you find St. John the Baptist Ukranian Catholic church almost literally "in the shadow of the grey giant." (see first link below)
http://www.clpgh.org/exhibit/neighborho ... _n223.htmlHere is another image:
http://www.clpgh.org/exhibit/neighborho ... _n221.htmlThe church is not an exact match to the silhouette in I12, but it's pretty close. Perspective based on where you're standing might also affect the match. From the photo in the second link, it seems that the stained-glass windows in the church are shaped just like I12.
If you start at the church and go about half a mile west on Carson street, passing under the Liberty bridge (a possible alternate explanation for the face of Liberty on the woman in Image 12?) you get to the foot of the Monongahela incline.
http://web.presby.edu/~jtbell/transit/i ... llView.jpgThe station sign saying Monongahela (after the nearby river, which was named for the native Monongahela Indian culture) could be the "sign nearby" that "speaks of Indies native" and I can tell you from experience that there is a serious whirring sound from the cables--the incline is really noisy! "Cars abound" here, definitely. "Carson" (a play on words?) street has lots of auto traffic. There are railroad tracks and a train station on the other side of the street (train cars) and the incline has cars, too. If you wanted to get cute, you could say that "cars abound" refers to the incline cars, which are bound to the track.
The "arm that extends over the slender path" could be the incline track itself--there are supposedly footpaths that go up Mt. Washington, but I have no idea if there is one near or under the incline. If you take the incline up, you get to Grandview Ave. Nearby to the east is Grandview Park. I haven't been there, so I am not sure if 22 steps ("twice as many east steps as the hour") would get you to from the top of the incline to the park, but it might. 22 steps might also refer to stairs near the bottom or top of the incline.
If you are at the top of the incline, on Mt. Washington, you have a view that allows you to "gaze north" (northwest, technically) "toward the isle of B" which would be Brunot Island, in the Ohio river.
I don't know who "him of Hard word" would be in this case. "Hard" makes me think of steel, and Pittsburgh is known as the Steel City. Perhaps one of the nineteenth-century steel tycoons like Carnegie or Frick? The area of the city that I'm describing used to be industrial, with iron, steel and glass works.
Other random ideas: the three droplets of water in Image 12 could represent Pittsburgh's famous three rivers. In Verse 10, the "simple roots in rhapsodic man's soil" might refer to the fact that Pittsburgh was the birthplace and childhood home of Oscar Levant, a pianist and actor who was the best friend of George "Rhapsody in Blue" Gershwin. Levant played himself in the movie "Rhapsody in Blue" and also recorded much of the movie's soundtrack, including the title track. From Grandview avenue (or park) you can see all of downtown Pgh, including the Hill district, where Levant grew up. Maybe there is a plaque or monument?
The eagle is the main thing making me question all of this, because I agree that it really does look like the gargoyle on the NYC Chrysler building. But could it be just an eagle? The only link I can come up with for my scenario is that the eagle relates to George Washington (as on the quarter-dollar coin, and in general USA symbology) and Mt. Washington is central here. Kind of weak, though...
Would love to hear anybody else's ideas on this. I thought it was interesting enough to rate a post, but maybe I just have too much time on my hands...
--Melanie
Last edited by macmail on Thu Jun 03, 2004 2:07 am, edited 1 time in total.